Sources of Light[diff: 21..22]

r21 () → r22 ()

notes on Without You


xml
  • 57 insertions
  • 0 deletions
  • +2,184 bytes
634 lines hidden
</p>
<hr />
<p>
    This evolved out of a keyboard riff I wrote in 2018. The first 16 bars of this
    song. Originally it was a little slower (around 120 BPM) but the notes were
    sixteenths instead of eighths. But I couldn't play it that fast on the guitar,
    and I couldn't come up with anything else besides that riff at that tempo, so
    I left it alone for six years or so. Eventually it turned into this.
</p>
<p>
    Originally it was just called "A&#x266d; thing". I don't have the original version
    from before I rewrote it in its enharmonic equivalent, though, so we'll just have
    to deal with all the &#x266f;'s.
</p>
<glacius:figure glacius:src="without-you-original.png" type="image">
    <caption>The origins of "Without You" from <glacius:date value="2018-05-08" /></caption>
</glacius:figure>
<hr />
<p>
    The guitar solo is actually doubled by the keyboards. This song was weird
    because it originally came from an idea on keyboard, and then it was all
    completely guitar-driven, and then I decided to take a mildly awkward
    guitar solo and play it on the keyboard, which extraordinarily awkward.
    Figuring out the fingering was the hardest part.
</p>
<hr />
<p>
    I decided to do an acoustic guitar "trio" near the end, that revisited
    verse 1's vocal melody (verse 4's, too, I guess). I think it ended up sounding
    pretty neat. Here it is isolated. Three guitars, with the main melody
    doubled and panned L+R.
</p>
<glacius:figure glacius:src="without-you-acoustic-excerpt.ogg" type="audio">
    <caption>Isoloated acoustic guitar trio, from 14:36-15:00</caption>
</glacius:figure>
<hr />
<p>
    The ending of the song was initially a <em>TBD</em> situation. The piano arpeggios
    were always meant to be there, but I worried it was just a little too gratuitious.
    And I was not wrong about that, but I chose to ignore my own trepidation.
</p>
<p>
    Here's the original transcription of the ending:
</p>
<glacius:figure glacius:src="without-you-end-original.png" type="image">
    <caption>Original transcribed ending of "Without You"</caption>
</glacius:figure>
<h4>Timing</h4>
<table class="table" style="max-width: 600px">
    <thead>
43 lines hidden